Franklin Templeton Mutual Funds Debt Scheme Closure
Franklin Templeton Mutual Funds Debt Scheme Closure

3 Myths Busted: Franklin Templeton Mutual Funds Debt Scheme Closure !

Even today (almost 10 years since I left school) I feel that the level of Financial Literacy in India still is in a bad shape. I’ve repeatedly spoken about this and will repeat again. People aren’t aware of the financial instruments available and have no idea how to build wealth. I’m sure you would have come across this recent news about Franklin Templeton Mutual Funds winding up 6 Debt Schemes in India. That did shake up the Mutual Funds industry. It benefited few investors but left many in a spot. And thanks to various universities like WhatsApp, Twitter and FaceBook, there are a lot of myths surrounding Franklin Templeton Mutual Funds in India.

So in this post, I’ll be busting 3 Myths associated with the Franklin Templeton Mutual Funds debt scheme closure. These are my views of the scenario along with inputs from my discussion with Mr Sanjay Sapre, President of Franklin Templeton Mutual Funds India that happened last evening. Gratitude to Mr. Sanjay for taking time off and interacting with bloggers to help us understand the situation and answering our questions patiently. The man’s got patience !

Franklin Templeton Mutual Funds Debt Scheme Closure
Franklin Templeton Mutual Funds Debt Scheme Closure

Why did Franklin Templeton Mutual Funds wind up 6 Debt Schemes ?

I’m a self taught financial planner with a keen interest in financial markets, planning and analysis. That means I’m no expert but I’m definitely more aware than the average person. Further, the whole scenario surrounding Franklin Templeton Mutual Funds was an interesting turn of events. So here’s what happened with Franklin Templeton Mutual Funds and why they decided to wind up 6 Debt Schemes. But first the basics. (If you are aware of the basics feel free to skip the next paragraph)

Basics of Debt Mutual Funds

Mutual Funds come in various flavors – Equity, Debt, Index, Thematic etc. Debt based mutual funds invest in securities like Corporate Bonds, Debentures (form of fixed deposit) etc. of other companies. The investments are often returned in form of coupons upon maturity. Most of these debt instruments are rated basis their performance and underlying asset quality like AAA (Highly secured) to D (Defaulter) Mutual Fund companies invest in these bonds and debentures and return the money to the investors upon maturity. That I feel is enough to know about Debt based mutual funds.

Franklin Templeton Mutual Funds – What happened ?

Franklin Templeton Mutual Funds has a basket of schemes and debt based scheme is one of them. Debt schemes of FT have been known for good returns over the past in the category. Why ? The funds invested in A rated bonds which were at a higher risk compared to AAA. Some of the companies included ILFS, DHFL, Yes Bank etc. I don’t know what risk category was listed for these schemes. And it’s common sense that higher the risk, higher the return. And this played well for them. Over the last few years debt schemes of Franklin Templeton Mutual Funds were providing good returns.

However due to the Corona Virus pandemic and the lockdown, they were hit by a crisis mainly due to two reasons. Firstly, due to businesses being closed, these small/medium companies where the fund invested were under stress. Secondly, due to the fear, the investors started pulling out money from the fund.

Result of COVID-19

This meant, FT was in a spot where it had to resort to borrowing from banks to repay the investors and on the other hand, the underlying securities were under stress. Due to reduced liquidity, it would affect the investors that are vested int the fund. That’s when they decided to wind up the following 6 Debt Schemes:

  • Franklin India Low Duration Fund
  • Franklin India Dynamic Accrual Fund
  • Franklin India Credit Risk Fund
  • Franklin India Short Term Income Plan
  • Franklin India Ultra Short Bond Fund
  • Franklin India Income Opportunities Fund

Winding up schemes means, there can be no purchase and redemption of units in the funds. So what happens next ? If you have invested in Franklin Templeton Mutual Funds Debt Scheme, have you lost your money ? Will you ever get back your money ?

Busting the 3 Myths of Franklin Templeton Mutual Funds

Myth 1: Investors will lose their Money

The collective AUM (Asset under Management) for these 6 Debt schemes is roughly 26,000 Cr. And with the winding up of the schemes, there is no buying or redeeming allowed. Hence the funds are frozen. So does that mean investors will lose their money ? The answer is NO, the investors have not lost their money. But yes the money will be stuck 🙁 I can totally understand the life savings people would have invested in these schemes. My heart goes out for them.

As mentioned, these debt schemes get returns in form of coupons at maturity. The scheme will be getting these coupons at the intervals and you will get your money back basis the coupon receipt. The question of when you will receive the money will depend upon of maturity of the underlying securities. Currently it is between 3 months to >5 years ! More details here.

Myth 2: Franklin Templeton is closing operations in India

With FT winding up 6 debt schemes, is Franklin Templeton Mutual Funds closing operations in India ? Absolutely No. They are a respected Mutual Fund company in India with huge investments. They have only wound up these 6 debt schemes but their other equity, ELSS, liquid schemes are not hampered. In short, they have not shut shop in India.

Myth 3: Don’t invest in Mutual Funds at all

We all know that Mutual Fund investments are subject to market risks, and the Covid 19 has hit hard and left the market bleeding. The bear market over the last few months have left the investor lurking. However, that doesn’t mean you should stop investing in Mutual Fund. With the markets at rock bottom, it is a good time to invest in the market**. And nothing better that SIPs to help you benefit from the market swings. In short, don’t stop your investments in mutual funds !

Mr. Sanjay Sapre, President – Franklin Templeton Mutual Funds India. Courtesy: YouTube

Closing Comments

It was an insightful session with Mr. Sanjay who patiently answered our questions on the happenings. These are tough times for markets across the globe and being an aware investor, I strongly believe that things will change. Rather it has started to improve. SENSEX and Nifty have been showing improvements over the last few weeks which is a good sign. Did you find this post helpful ? Were your questions answered about Franklin Templeton Mutual Funds debt schemes ? What do you think can be improved ? Mention in the comments below or tweet to me at @Atulmaharaj or DM me in Instagram.

** These are my personal views on the scenario. Request you to reach out to your financial advisor to understand more and identify the right financing opportunities. And like always, Mutual Fund investments are subject to market risks, please read the scheme related documents carefully before investing. Further, my heart goes out to the investors who have been hurt by this fiasco. The financial institutions in India need to strengthen and better governance should be in place.

About Atulmaharaj

Maintaining the blog for the past 6 years, I'm a Foodie, Techie, Cricket Enthu, Traveler, Blogger and a Cook ! You'll find posts within a wide range of topics from food to technology. Favorite Quote: "Traveling is like reading a book, one who hasn't traveled, hasn't turned a page.

Check Also

Pradhan Mantri Mudra Yojana Essential Guide

Essential Guide to Pradhan Mantri Mudra Yojana Loan

Economic reforms are important for the growth of any country. While most of us (the …

8 comments

  1. The most important reason for a retail investor/lot of canvassing by many including NSE/AMFI to invest in mutual funds is that FUND MANAGERS are professionals who can manage the fund far better than you can do yourself.

    In the context of winding of six schemes by Franklin India, it is highlighted that redemptions in March/April, 2020 were equally very high across many Fund Houses and even more than that of Franklin India, in few cases. And redemption pressure was not isolated/unique for Franklin India.

    However, all other Fund Houses could manage such heavy or heavier redemptions in March/April, 2020 and could keep the Ultra Short Fund category live even in the face of such heavy redemptions unlike Franklin India.

    Considering above and the fact that no other Fund House was required to wind up schemes clearly implies that the strategy of investments by Franklin India was the sole reason for the winding up. Hence, Franklin India has responsibility to bear the consequences of the failure of their strategies at least partly if not in full.

    Whereas their actions post winding up only suggest that the losses due to their mismanagement are being imposed completely on the unit holders.

    And the very fact Franklin India did not give any indication that they are ready to bear at least a part of shortfall in realizing the investments does not inspire confidence that they are serious in maximizing the refund to investors. Mere statements without any financial commitment from Franklin India amount to only a lip service to divert the attention of investors from real underlying issues, if any.

    This needs deliberation in the forum.

    • Thanks Pavan for your views on this. I totally agree with you on that fact that Mutual Funds are suggested to investors because of their experience. Probably the red flag could have been raised a little earlier so this situation wouldn’t have arised.

    • Hehe..true. My dad jokes many times, “Poora paisa ek ghanni bag mein bharke ghar pe rakh lete hain :P”

  2. NBFC , Private Banks Cooperative bank , MF and next is what ? Last 6 month has been horrific & scary for Financial sector and lockdown will make it way bigger . Best is hold the ship for next 6 month , invest in govt securities or PSU FD’s or Post office scheme . We all like to earn amazing return but reult of investing is never to lose your principal .

    • Totally Chandresh, debt schemes that are generally meant to be safe bets over equity are hurt too. In this case the choice of bonds they invested in. One led to another and boom ! Nothing’s safe and everything is risky. And with Covid, you never know what’s next as your rightly said.

  3. I really loved your post. Its insightful & in fact I learnt few new things.

Share your thoughts

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Are You Serious ?


You should not leave without signing up for our newsletter !

Get a weekly digest of all the posts from the blog delivered right to your inbox, just a click away, Sign Up Now !
PS: We hate Spam too, We promise, we'll never spam.
Name
Email address
Secure and Spam free...
%d bloggers like this: